Reading sucoder replies from agent transcripts: observed facts
Table of Contents
- Summary: what breaks "find the message id, take the next assistant message"
- 1. Claude Code, this session (ln002.brc, default tmux server)
- 2. Codex, CerealDemand job 40401999 (n0198.savio4, managed codexstate)
- 3. Claude Code, LSMSLibrary job 40390255 (n0114.savio4)
- Note: the human's separate-channel suggestion (IRC), 2026-10-23 08:40
- Reproduce
Answer to message 00cd from the SuCoder agent on lyn (issue 52 follow-up).
Everything below was observed read-only between 08:30 and 08:40 PDT on 2026-10-23.
No pane was typed into or captured, and nothing was killed.
Remote reads went through srun --jobid=J --overlap --quiet --chdir=/tmp bash -s < script (steps 39 and 81).
Line numbers in Claude transcripts are 1-based file lines.
Codex lines are cited by their ordinal field, which equals the 0-based line index.
Summary: what breaks "find the message id, take the next assistant message"
- The message is not always a
userentry. Claude Code delivers a message typed while it is busy as aqueue-operationplus anattachmentof typequeued_command, not as auserentry (LSMSLibrary, message 1733). Codex injects it into the running turn as aresponse_itemwithrole: user, sameturn_idas the work already under way (CerealDemand, message 8e25). - The message text is not at the start of the content.
A long
send-keys -lburst reached this Claude session as a paste: theusercontent is the string"\n\n<pasted_content id\"935c\">\n[message 00cd …\n</pastedcontent id=\"935c\">\n". An anchored =^\[messagematch fails. The paste id is not unique: a later paste into this same session reusedid"935c"=. - The id appears in many entries that are not the delivery.
Claude:
last-prompt(truncated, ends in U+2026),api-request-blob(copies of request content, both roles),tool_resultentries that echoed it, and the compaction summary (isCompactSummary: true). Codex: theevent_msg/item_completedtwin of every item,compacted.payload.replacement_history, and the copied history of every subagent thread forked after the message (same itemidas the parent's copy).grep 'message 8e25'hits 6 of the 8 CerealDemand rollouts; only one is the delivery. - The next assistant entry is usually not the reply.
Claude writes one JSONL entry per content block; after a message come thinking blocks, tooluse blocks and preamble text.
In this session the first assistant text after 00cd is the bootstrap line
"I'm Sue, running on Claude Opus 5.5. ...". Codex emitscommentarymessages before tool calls, and the main thread also receivesresponse_item/agent_messageitems from subagents. - The reply can come mid-turn and be
commentary. Codex'sREPLY 8e25: ok.hasphase: "commentary", 2 s after delivery, inside a turn that ran from 13:42:59Z to 15:04:38Z. Waiting fortask_completeor filtering onfinal_answerwould wait an hour or miss it. - The reply may never come, and the summary may say it did.
LSMSLibrary has no assistant entry mentioning 1733 at all, yet its later compaction summary says the relay message was
(answered "REPLY 1733: ok"). If your--waitorpeekdid see aREPLY 1733on that screen, the transcript is missing something the screen showed, which would be a deeper break. If it did not, a mid-turn message can be silently dropped by the model. - The reply string also appears in tool inputs.
Any agent that writes about the protocol (this file, for one) puts
REPLY <id>:into atool_useinput. Match only Claudetype: "assistant"entries with atextblock, or Codexresponse_itemwithpayload.type: "message"androle: "assistant". - File order is not timestamp order (Claude).
The
queued_commandattachment carries the enqueue time (02:55:15.671Z) but is written after a 02:55:50.362Ztool_result; its file position marks when the model saw it. Use file position for "after" in Claude andordinalin Codex. - Finding the file is not solved for compute-node Claude sessions (see section 3).
A matcher that survives all of the above: locate the delivery entry by its harness-specific shape (not by grep), then take the first assistant text item after that position whose text has a line matching ^REPLY <id>:, with a deadline; report "no reply" rather than falling back to "next assistant message".
1. Claude Code, this session (ln002.brc, default tmux server)
Path and discovery
- Transcript
/global/home/users/ligon/.claude/projects/-global-scratch-fsa-fc-jevons-ligon-mirrors-SuCoder/83cd9e50-d565-4635-95a2-da82d4b334cd.jsonl- Config dir
CLAUDE_CONFIG_DIRunset, so~/.claudeon NFS home, the same directory from login and compute nodes.- Project dir
- the cwd with
/and_replaced by-(fc_jevonsbecamefc-jevons;LSMS_LibrarybecameLSMS-Library). Other characters were not observed. - Session id
- the transcript basename. From outside it is in
~/.claude/sessions/<pid>.jsonwhen that file exists. - Session registry
~/.claude/sessions/4016127.json(pid ofclaude) hassessionId,cwd,tmux: "sucoder-SuCoder:@0.%0",status: "busy",pidDomain,messagingSocketPath,version: "2.1.309". Thetmuxfield maps a sucoder session name straight to a session id, andstatuswould tell you when the turn is over. It is not reliable for compute-node sessions (section 3).- Launch
tmux new-session -A -s sucoder-SuCoder claude --system-prompt ... --dangerously-skip-permissions; exec bash -lon the default socket; panealternate_on=0,history_size=44at 08:31.- Pinning
claude --help(2.1.309) lists--session-id <uuid>. Launching with a uuid sucoder chooses would make the path deterministic. Not tested, and not known to survive/clearor--resume.
The entry holding message 00cd (line 10)
{"parentUuid": "8f2dfa31-...", "isSidechain": false,
"promptId": "926b7031-...", "type": "user",
"message": {"role": "user",
"content": "\n\n<pasted_content id=\"935c\">\n[message 00cd from ligon@lyn via sucoder, 2026-10-23 08:29] Hi, ... Reply when done.\n</pasted_content id=\"935c\">\n"},
"uuid": "40183fc8-...", "timestamp": "2026-10-23T15:29:41.057Z",
"permissionMode": "bypassPermissions", "origin": {"kind": "human"},
"promptSource": "typed", "turnOrigin": "human",
"turnPosition": {"promptIndex": 1, "turnIndex": 1},
"userType": "external", "entrypoint": "cli",
"cwd": "/global/scratch/fsa/fc_jevons/ligon/mirrors/SuCoder",
"sessionId": "83cd9e50-...", "version": "2.1.309", "gitBranch": "main"}
content is a string here because the session was idle; tool results make it a list.
Nothing marks it as a sucoder message except the text: origin.kind is "human" and promptSource is "typed".
Shape of an assistant reply entry
My reply to 00cd does not exist yet as I write this; it will be appended after this file is written, in the same shape as this existing text entry (line 33):
{"parentUuid": "c58a866f-...", "isSidechain": false,
"message": {"model": "claude-opus-5-5", "id": "msg_011CgKQaA7gjwYRp2m9tR2T5",
"type": "message", "role": "assistant",
"content": [{"type": "text", "text": "I'm Sue, running on Claude Opus 5.5. ..."}],
"stop_reason": "tool_use", "usage": {...}, ...},
"apiBlockIndex": 1, "requestId": "req_011CgKQa9oqwatkUvemNJg8U",
"type": "assistant", "uuid": "ba473610-...",
"timestamp": "2026-10-23T15:29:58.772Z", "sessionId": "83cd9e50-...", ...}
- One entry per content block. Blocks of one API response share
message.idandrequestIdand are numbered byapiBlockIndex; the thinking block before this one (line 32) has the samemessage.id. parentUuidchains throughattachmententries, so the user entry is an ancestor of the reply, not its parent.- The final reply should have
stop_reason: "end_turn"; intermediate text has"tool_use". - The
REPLYline can sit inside a longer text block; match per line.
Find it after the fact with:
python3 -I - ~/.claude/projects/-global-scratch-fsa-fc-jevons-ligon-mirrors-SuCoder/83cd9e50-d565-4635-95a2-da82d4b334cd.jsonl <<'EOF'
import json, re, sys
pat = re.compile(r'^REPLY 00cd:.*$', re.M)
for n, l in enumerate(open(sys.argv[1]), 1):
d = json.loads(l)
if d.get('type') != 'assistant': continue
for b in d['message']['content']:
if b.get('type') == 'text':
for m in pat.finditer(b['text']): print(n, d['timestamp'], m.group(0))
EOF
Other entry types in 2.1.309 that carry message text: last-prompt (lastPrompt, truncated), api-request-blob (message.role user or assistant, full content), and api-request / api-request-shape (request metadata).
2. Codex, CerealDemand job 40401999 (n0198.savio4, managed codexstate)
Paths
- Scope
0f536c4f2f4494488b4b9988cb965bb6427ecd32422bb11c4d3de83b91689ceb(from the runner argv--scope, or by scanningrun.jsonforallocation.job)- Run
c48a7b0918ac41d09fe39250a4f3d160(also in/local/job40401999/state/codex/<scope>/latest-run)- Main thread
01a168ea-5cfb-76b1-98d0-ab68f8fd2af6- Node-local rollout
/local/job40401999/state/codex/<scope>/<run>/home/sessions/2026/10/23/rollout-2026-10-23T06-19-12-01a168ea-5cfb-76b1-98d0-ab68f8fd2af6.jsonl(the timestamp in the name is local time, PDT)- Durable replica
/global/home/users/ligon/mirrors/.sucoder-state/codex/<scope>/runs/<run>/rollouts/01a168ea-5cfb-76b1-98d0-ab68f8fd2af6.jsonl(Lustre; norollout-prefix, no date directories).run.jsonbeside it hasallocation.job,allocation.node,codex_home,codex_home_real.- Shared home
- bwrap binds the node-local
home/sessionsover/global/scratch/fsa/fc_jevons/ligon/codex-home/sessions(the realpath of~/.codex/sessions). Outside the namespace~/.codex/sessions/2026/10/23/does not exist.
Readable from outside bwrap?
Yes.
An srun --overlap --jobid=40401999 step (outside the namespace) listed and grepped the node-local rollouts directly; bwrap binds are per-process and do not hide the source directories.
The durable replica needs no srun at all; it is readable from the login node.
Script files in the login node's /tmp are not visible on the compute node; feed them on stdin.
Replica lag at 08:33:47, :52 and :57: local = replica= for the main thread each time (7448219, 7449904, 7458344 bytes).
status.json in the node-local run directory has replica.threads.<id>.{local_bytes, replicated_bytes, relative_path} and replica.lag_bytes, but status.json itself is node-local, not durable.
The replica grows by appending, so a reader may see a partial last line; parse only newline-terminated lines (inferred from the runner's design, not observed).
Process tree under the runner: bwrap -> bash -c wrapper -> codex app-server --remote-control (writes the rollouts) plus the TUI codex --remote unix:///tmp/sucoder-codex-A23y20U0/server.sock.
session_meta says cli_version: "0.163.0", originator: "sucoder_remote_control", source: "vscode".
Emu-GMM (job 40401644) runs a second managed Codex on the same node under /local/job40401644.
Threads in this run
session_meta (line 0 of each rollout) tells the main thread from forks:
01a168ea...thread_source: "user",forked_from_id: null. The main thread.- seven others
thread_source: "subagent",forked_from_id: "01a168ea...",source.subagent.thread_spawn.{parent_thread_id, depth, agent_path, agent_nickname}(Confucius, Euler, Boyle, Curie, Hume, Euclid, Jason).
Shape of the user input item (message 8e25, ordinal 756)
{"timestamp": "2026-10-23T13:59:59.275Z", "ordinal": 756, "type": "response_item",
"payload": {"type": "message", "id": "msg_01a1690f-b42b-7ad1-a7c0-10bd826e920b", "role": "user",
"content": [{"type": "input_text",
"text": "[message 8e25 from coder@lyn (relay) via sucoder, 2026-10-23 06:59] Relay test from the SuCoder agent (sucoder message via coder). No action needed; please just reply ok."}],
"internal_chat_message_metadata_passthrough": {"turn_id": "01a16900-2503-7120-829f-13f1c0b3532a",
"create_time": 1792763999.2750137,
"content_item_kinds": ["user.text"]}},
"metadata": {"retained_source": ...}}
Twin at ordinal 757: type: "event_msg", payload.type: "item_completed", payload.item: {"type": "UserMessage", "id": ..., "client_id": ..., "content": [{"type": "text", "text": "[message 8e25 ...", "text_elements": []}]}.
The text arrived byte-identical, with no paste wrapper.
Shape of the assistant message item (the reply, ordinal 761)
{"timestamp": "2026-10-23T14:00:01.420Z", "ordinal": 761, "type": "response_item",
"payload": {"type": "message", "status": "completed",
"id": "msg_096a9bf5b0265704016adb686106348190a7f3f5573be690ac", "role": "assistant",
"content": [{"type": "output_text", "text": "REPLY 8e25: ok.", "annotations": [], "logprobs": []}],
"phase": "commentary",
"internal_chat_message_metadata_passthrough": {"turn_id": "01a16900-2503-7120-829f-13f1c0b3532a", ...}},
"metadata": {...}}
Twin at ordinal 760: event_msg/item_completed with item.type: "AgentMessage", item.content: [{"type": "Text", "text": "REPLY 8e25: ok."}], item.phase: "commentary".
Between 757 and 760 there is a reasoning item (758/759); after 761 the turn goes on with tool calls.
Here the "next assistant message" happened to be the reply; with a commentary preamble before a tool call it would not have been.
Main-thread totals: message items by role/phase are developer 3, user 7, assistant/commentary 70, assistant/finalanswer 4; there are also 71 agent_message items (subagent to /root, encrypted payload, author=/=recipient paths) and 3 compacted entries.
Turn bounds are event_msg task_started / task_complete with turn_id.
Every place message 8e25 occurs
| thread | ordinal | kind |
|---|---|---|
| 01a168ea (main) | 756 | responseitem message user (the delivery) |
| 01a168ea (main) | 757 | eventmsg itemcompleted UserMessage |
| 01a168ea (main) | 2371 | compacted, replacementhistory[7] (user item; the reply is not kept) |
| 01a168ea (main) | 3511 | compacted |
| 01a16918 Boyle | 5 | responseitem message user, forked copy with the parent's item id |
| 01a16936 Curie | 5 | responseitem message user, forked copy with the parent's item id |
| 01a16954 Hume | 2 | compacted (fork seed) |
| 01a1695b-184d Euclid | 2 | compacted (fork seed) |
| 01a1695b-2c64 Jason | 2 | compacted (fork seed) |
Confucius and Euler forked at 13:43, before the message, and do not contain it.
REPLY 8e25 occurs only at ordinals 760 and 761 of the main thread.
3. Claude Code, LSMSLibrary job 40390255 (n0114.savio4)
Path and discovery
- Process
claudepid 1377789 on n0114, up 13:09:39 at 08:35, exe~/.local/share/claude/versions/2.1.309, cwd/local/job40390255/mirrors/LSMS_Library.- Environment
CLAUDE_CONFIG_DIRunset;HOME=/global/home/users/ligon;TMUX=/tmp/tmux-43292/sucoder-LSMS_Library,1377218,0;SUCODER_LOCAL_ROOT=/local/job40390255.- Transcript
/global/home/users/ligon/.claude/projects/-local-job40390255-mirrors-LSMS-Library/aad69bbf-39c1-40e1-bf95-cbd7d49b5cce.jsonl(16 MB), on shared home, readable from the login node without srun.- Registry
- there is no
~/.claude/sessions/1377789.json, seen from either n0114 or ln002. The only other entry,2933040.json, is Emu-GMM in job 40371651, which is no longer insqueue: stale. So the registry cannot be relied on to find a compute-node session. - Open files
/proc/1377789/fdholds no.jsonl; Claude appends and closes, solsof-style discovery does not work.- Fallback
- encode the job-local cwd into the project dir name and take the newest
*.jsonlthere. Because the cwd contains the job id, the directory is per-allocation; this one holds a single transcript. Subagent transcripts are in<session-id>/subagents/agent-*.jsonl; none of them mention =[message =.
How message 1733 was delivered (agent busy in a Bash call)
line 1025 {"type": "queue-operation", "operation": "enqueue",
"timestamp": "2026-10-23T02:55:15.767Z", "sessionId": "aad69bbf-...",
"content": "[message 1733 from ligon's Claude Code session@lyn (via coder) via sucoder, 2026-10-22 19:55] Connectivity test ... please just answer with a REPLY line saying ok."}
line 1026 {"type": "user", ... tool_result ..., "timestamp": "2026-10-23T02:55:50.362Z"}
line 1027 {"type": "queue-operation", "operation": "remove", "reason": "absorbed_mid_turn",
"commandUuid": "4b15136f-...", "deliveryId": "b74cf907-...",
"timestamp": "2026-10-23T02:55:50.410Z", "content": "[message 1733 ..."}
line 1031 {"type": "attachment", "parentUuid": "9ff816c9-..." (the tool_result),
"attachment": {"type": "queued_command", "prompt": "[message 1733 ...",
"source_uuid": "4b15136f-...", "delivery_id": "b74cf907-...",
"commandMode": "prompt", "origin": {"kind": "human"},
"timestamp": "2026-10-23T02:55:15.671Z", "humanTurn": true},
"rendered": [{"content": "<system-reminder>\nThe user sent a new message while you were working:\n[message 1733 ..."}],
"renderedRole": "system", "timestamp": "2026-10-23T02:55:15.671Z", ...}
The message waited 35 s for the running tool to finish and reached the model inside a system reminder next to a tool result.
Delivery when a turn ends with the queue non-empty (a dequeue into an ordinary user turn, presumably) was not observed.
Your mid-turn message to this session arrived the same way, as a system reminder after a tool result.
No reply
From the delivery (line 1031) to the next visible text (line 1123, "PR #1222 is open. ...") there are only thinking and Bash tooluse blocks, and the thinking summaries are about the Mali work.
No assistant entry anywhere in the file contains 1733.
REPLY 1733 occurs only in the compaction summary (line 4631, type: "user", isCompactSummary: true, after the compact_boundary) and in two api-request-blob copies of it (lines 4615, 4664), as the summarizer's claim (answered "REPLY 1733: ok").
A grep for the reply string would therefore report a reply that the transcript does not contain.
Note: the human's separate-channel suggestion (IRC), 2026-10-23 08:40
The human raised a dedicated channel (IRC, e.g. Ergo) instead of screen or transcript reading. My assessment, for whoever designs this:
- The facts above argue against making sucoder parse two private, fast-moving transcript formats (both harnesses grew new entry types recently). Use transcript reading as a diagnostic, not the protocol.
- Any out-of-band channel only fixes the reply path, and only if the agent sends its reply through it with a tool call instead of printing it. That change, not the transport, is what fixes this bug.
- Inbound delivery still needs
send-keys(or a harness-native channel): idle agents do not poll a socket. - Claude Code already has a harness-native one, unexplored here:
~/.claude/sessions/4016127.jsonhaspeerProtocol: 1,peerFeatures: ["notify_idle", "reply_across_default_dirs", "artifact_yield"]andmessagingSocketPath: "/run/user/43292/cc-socks/4016127.sock", and n0114 has/local/job40390255/cc-socks-43292/. It is a Unix socket (same host only) and Claude-only; Codex has nothing equivalent that I saw. - A file mailbox on shared home (the agent runs
sucoder reply <id> "text", or writes~/.sucoder/mail/<id>.replyitself; the sender polls that path over its existing SSH route) gives the same effect with no daemon, no open port and Unix permissions for auth. - IRC adds a long-running service (login nodes are a poor host; compute-node addresses change at turnover), a listening port on the cluster network, and an authentication requirement: whatever can post into a channel that feeds agents running with
--dangerously-skip-permissionscan run commands on the cluster. - No channel helps with message 1733: an agent that ignores a mid-turn message has to be caught by a deadline and a "no reply" result.
Reproduce
# Codex: which threads contain an id, and as what (login node, durable replica)
R=~/mirrors/.sucoder-state/codex/0f536c4f2f4494488b4b9988cb965bb6427ecd32422bb11c4d3de83b91689ceb/runs/c48a7b0918ac41d09fe39250a4f3d160/rollouts
grep -c 'message 8e25' $R/*.jsonl
# Node-local view, outside bwrap
TMPDIR=/tmp srun --jobid=40401999 --overlap --quiet --chdir=/tmp \
find /local/job40401999/state/codex -name 'rollout-*.jsonl' -exec grep -l 'message 8e25' {} +
# Claude: every entry type that mentions an id
grep -n 'message 1733' ~/.claude/projects/-local-job40390255-mirrors-LSMS-Library/aad69bbf-39c1-40e1-bf95-cbd7d49b5cce.jsonl | cut -c1-120